Monday, 3 May 2010

Whaling and NGOs II







The BLOG about whaling posted by Sophie made me curious and I wanted to do more research on the issue as it has been around for a while. Nevertheless we keep hearing updates regarding conflict between anti-whaling protesters and Japan. So I wanted to understand the depth of the problem. I do not want to take either side as this issue is a very controversial one. But we have to notice that both the Japanese authorities and anti-whaling protesters are acting under regulations of international agreements and Laws. As Sophie (2010, Feb) mentioned earlier. "The UN World Charter for Nature, section 21, empowers any nongovernmental organisation or individual to uphold international conservation law in areas beyond national jurisdiction and specifically on the high seas."(Monday, 22 February 2010 Whaling in Antarctica, The Sea Shepherd organisation are a group of anti whaling). This extraction does empowers Greenpeace and other NGOs united under the name of WHALEWATCH (40 NGOs) to try confront Japanese whalers in order to affect their abilities to hunt whales. The fact that international criminal laws in international waters are difficult to regulate does allow anti-whaling activists to assault and attack private Japanese Boats (Which are operating under the Institute of Cetacean Research) and usually allow to remain legally unchallenged by Japanese or international authorities. And Japanese authorities state that International Convention for the Regulation of Whaling (ICRW) Article VIII of the ICRW clearly states that: ‘…any Contracting Government may grant to any of its nationals a special permit authorizing that national to kill, take and treat whales for purposes of scientific research subject to such restrictions as to number and subject to such other conditions as the Contracting Government thinks fit, and the killing, taking, and treating of whales in accordance with the provisions of this Article shall be exempt from the operation of this Convention…’. Both sides do have a strong argument and as long as Japan is acting within legal guidelines no one will be able to stop them. On the other hand it is claimed that Japanese whaling is based on scientific research. If some samples of whale meat are taken in the name of study and the rest of the whale would be thrown to rot in the pit rather than sold to Japanese consumers or restaurants? Would that be reasonable and justified by anti-whaling activists? The main argument arises within the issue of brutality against the animal and animal rights. No one seem to care what happens to the whale after the catch or how it affects the research. Similar tensions were raised in Great Britain when political debate regarding ban on fox hunting attracted attention of many activists. Any image of animal cruelty will raise many negative protests but any kind of those protests have to be justified and reasonable. The extreme actions by NGOs are attracting worldwide attention but are powerless unless the member states of International Whaling Commission (IWC) take action to extract sections of international agreements that allow countries like Japan to continue whaling. I personally think the actions of radical anti whaling protesters possess some amount of unreasonable assaults and criminal damage towards Japanese ships and crews. Some might disagree to the actions of Japanese, but even if Japanese are engaged in unreasonable whaling within the laws no NGO should be above the international criminal law. Maybe NGOs should direct their efforts in more reasonable anti whaling law making based on research rather than dangerous physical actions against the whaling ships crews. And this might result in NGO image damaging:



The head of ‘Sea Shepherd’ Paul Watson. Japan issued an arrest warrant due to his actions. But he insists that “As long as we are chasing them, they aren't killing whales”.












In 2008 two members of Japanese Greenpeace movement (Junichi Sato, 31, and Toru Suzuki, 41) were arrested by Japanese authorities for presenting the stolen whale meat as an evidence. the question is whether he was arrested for disclosing the truth and whether Japanese authorities need that truth. The act of theft took place first as he had to obtain the evidence, therefore the criminal element will always attract more negativity.



Friday, 30 April 2010

My understanding of diplomacy today

My perception of diplomacy has changed a lot since the beginning of the course. At the outset I didn’t know much about the topic. I looked at diplomacy merely as the interstate negotiations and the tool for the peaceful conduct of international relations.

Therefore, the module developed significantly my knowledge. It showed the evolution of diplomatic practice- a complex issue as it is difficult to even indicate with certainty when exactly diplomacy has started. It presented different phases in diplomacy- the very beginnings of the modern diplomacy back in Renaissance Italy where institution of permanent embassies emerged; its further development until the twentieth century, when diplomacy massively expanded, many new state and non-state actors have ‘joined in’ increasing numbers and types of diplomatic links. Diplomacy has changed its nature- it is no more just about bilateral negotiations between two states, but now, particularly in the twentieth century, the role of multilateral or conference diplomacy has been constantly growing. Additionally, the twentieth century have witnessed many more developments and innovations in diplomacy. The growing importance of various NGOs in diplomacy can be deemed as a positive development, on the other hand, however, there has been constant and gradual decrease in importance carried by classic institution of diplomacy, and the role of ambassador has been also undermined, as currently diplomacy is often conducted by politicians.

My Opinion on Today's Diplomacy

Diplomacy plays very significant role in the contemporary world of politics. It can be force for good by creating channel of communication among conflicting sides as well as helping to establish, innovate and foster global peace and security. I always believed that diplomacy is function sole for foreign office and its representative. However, since I started this module, 'the New Diplomacy', I discover that it goes fur deeper beyond the surface. Diplomacy involves by non state actors such as NGOs and it also has important role for the environment, trade and crisis.

The new diplomacy has given me the opportunity to explore this subject further. I have learned that diplomacy facilitates channel of communication among heads of states and non state politics in contemporary world of politics. Without communication, there would not be any international system as there will not be any interaction among states and non state actors. I have also learned the transformation of diplomacy from old to new, bilateral to multilateral and from secrecy to more open and honest.

The negotiation of agreements is plays crual role for enhancing relationships and achieving mutual benefits, thus diplomacy facilitates states actor to interact with minimum frication and tension.

In my opinion, the most interesting thing that I have learned in this module is the growing significant role of NGOs in diplomatic circle which I have underestimated in the past. At the sometime, there has been a decree in important of one traditional diplomacy core aspects; role of ambassador has been undermined.

New Diplomacy module has enlightened my knowledge and understanding of diplomacy today

Diplomacy plays an extremely important role in world politics. An effective diplomacy can help to establish and maintain international peace and security. My opinion about this crucial role of diplomacy in the world politics has not changed the since of New Diplomacy module. However my opinion, about what diplomacy is, has been changed since the start of this module.

I used to think that when the heads of states interact with one another, these interactions are regarded as diplomatic activities. But New Diplomacy module has influenced my thinking. It can be argued that politicians may not be diplomats. Distinctions can be drawn between politicians and diplomats. Unlike old diplomacy, new diplomacy tends to be low politics rather than high politics.

The module has greatly enhanced my knowledge of this subject. I have learned about the history of diplomacy, its different forms and various ongoing debates. One of the interesting things I learned about diplomacy is its transformation or transition from old to new.

Perhaps most unexpected discovery about diplomacy is the role of some NGO’s in diplomatic activities. Diplomacy in my opinion was beyond the reach of NGO’s. But I was surprised to learn that in multilateral diplomacy, sometimes NGO’s have role too. These knowledge and understanding of diplomacy has made me more aware of NGO’s important role in diplomacy today.

Thursday, 29 April 2010

Efficiency of the new diplomacy:

The new diplomacy has brought about cooperation between NGOs and multilateral cooperation due to the impact of globalisation which has made trade, investment, travel and information technology much closer to each other. Another important aspect of the new diplomacy is that international law has come into force compared to the 19th and 20th century whereby it was limited to issues such as piracy, wartime embargoes, rights of diplomats which was all about states thus through multilateralism, states have come into agreement through the UN and the EU whereby international law has been put into place and of which states have to abide by it especially when it comes to human rights (Katz, E. Feb.10, 2006).

With the advance of new technology, new diplomacy has made it easy for information to bypass resident ambassadors in a way that coverage such as the media can transfer messages. Example CNN coverage of the Gulf war (Berridge, G.R. 2005:119-120). New diplomacy has also shaped the importance of smaller poor states in a way that they do lack technology due to financial hardships and thus by states coming together through conferences, these countries can easily express their cases like in the UN and also get help in specific fields where they need expertise, for instance when it comes to trade tariffs (Monteiro, A. 29th March 1995).

Last point to make is that it has made travel and work for foreign secretaries much easier in that they can move from one place to another negotiating directly with foreign missions in which they are respected just like the resident ambassador (Taylor, pp. 97-98, 106, 181) and also a leader can send his message directly to a foreign land with the use of modern technology just like Barrack Obama did during his address to the Iranian people.


Berridge, G.R. (2005), Diplomacy: theory and Practice, 3rd edition, New York: Palgrave Houndmills, Basingstoke.
Katz, E. (2006), Business-NGO Alliance marks “New Diplomacy,” Pell says. Retrieved on 26/04/2010. From: http://www.law.virginia.edu/html/news/2006-spr/pell.htm
Monteiro, A. (1995), multilateral diplomacy: diplomacy in transition. Retrieved: 05/04/2010. From: http://www.mfa.gov.il/MFA/MFAArchive/1990_1999/1998/12/MULTILATERAL%20DIPOMACY%20-%2029-Mar-95

Importance of public diplomacy in the contemporary world:

In the present contemporary world with the spread of democracy has created a new environment in the international system to win hearts and minds of people by governments. This is what public diplomacy does by trying to influence foreign nationals and the public with values, policies and actions of their governments to be supported. Public diplomacy can be defined as the efforts of one nation to influence public or elites of the next nation for the purpose of using foreign policy to its target. Governments always attempt to communicate with foreign public to export their ideas, its institutions and culture, as well as national goals and current policies.

Public diplomacy looks at promoting its culture for long term aims while short-term when it comes to current foreign policies and can also be looked at as propaganda for a nation state by improving its image abroad which will be favourable to the state. The importance of foreign public diplomacy is that it is influenced by soft power rather than use of force or hard power and has brought dependency of citizens on their governments and the local press for information on foreign events and increased potential targets for direct communication of diplomatic messages.

Another important point is that distribution of information around the globe is not restricted due to new technology that can transmit messages around the world in seconds like with fighting terrorism in an age of global real-time television and the internet. Public diplomacy also serves both bilateral and multilateral diplomacy in the sense that they are intended for national interest like in the quest of investment, promotion of trade, and international tourism which is also referred to as branding and also creates cooperation and interaction. Example can be seen in the Canadian and Norwegian experience with the Ottawa process on landmines which shows how collaboration between the domestic and international policy arenas and the public and private sphere (Smith, P.H. Public diplomacy).


Smith, P.H. Public diplomacy, by Minister-Counsellor for Public Affairs, U.S. Embassy, London. Retrieved on 26/04/2010. From: http://www.diplomact.edu/books/mdiplomacy-book/smith/p.h.%20smith.htm

Relevance of bilateral diplomacy in contemporary world:

Bilateral diplomacy is still relevant in the contemporary world in that usually when negotiations take place, it is much easier on a face to face basis whereby leaders do come together (bilaterally) and discuss issues of importance. Because of this, we find out that dialogue can be met because of physical contact and sign language which builds more trust amongst people. In bilateral diplomacy, missions are usually based abroad thus an ambassador or resident mission is well informed to the local environment such as language and culture of which he/she can easily integrate into that society and build trust among the locals (Berridge, G.R. 2005:121-122).

Another importance of bilateral diplomacy is that it does have first hand information. This is an important factor in that by having a resident mission, mutual relationship is built and at the same time the geopolitical factor arises in that the ambassador will be well informed and have good knowledge about the culture, the people and the day to day activities of that country compared to a foreign secretary who is so mobile and has loads of assignments at his disposal with limited time to get to know about a particular place or area.


Berridge, G.R. (2005), Diplomacy: theory and Practice, 3rd edition, New York: Palgrave Houndmills, Basingstoke.